RFK Rankings · Florence
Best Wine Lists in Florence 2026
Restaurant cellars & sommelier programs · Florence · 7 lists ranked · Updated June 2026
Compiled by the Restaurants for Kings editorial team · Published June 18, 2026 · Updated June 20, 2026
Sixty thousand bottles sit beneath Enoteca Pinchiorri on Via Ghibellina, around 4,000 labels deep, the cellar most often called a cathedral of wine and the reason Florence belongs in any serious wine conversation. The city pairs that one global landmark with a row of rooms built on Tuscany itself: Super Tuscan verticals at the Four Seasons, riverside cellars over the Ponte Vecchio, and Oltrarno osterie that read a Chianti list like a map. Here is who each table suits, what to expect walking in, and how to book it. Seven, ranked on depth, the pairing program and value rather than trophy labels alone.
1.Enoteca Pinchiorri
Italy's three-star cathedral of wine, 60,000 bottles deep on Via Ghibellina. Save it for a landmark bottle.
Enoteca Pinchiorri began in 1972 as Giorgio Pinchiorri and Annie Feolde's wine shop and is now one of only a handful of Italian restaurants holding three Michelin stars. The cellar runs past 60,000 bottles and roughly 4,000 labels from 19 countries, with old vintages of Petrus, Mouton-Rothschild and Romanee-Conti, a Wine Spectator Grand Award room led by head sommelier Alessandro Tomberli over Riccardo Monco's kitchen. This is the city's grand wine occasion, the room for marking something with an aged Tuscan or Burgundian bottle. Plan on 300 euro and up before wine. Reserve three to four weeks ahead, name a region and a number, and ask Tomberli's team to open the cellar.
Book on the Pinchiorri site; ask the sommelier to walk you into the older verticals.
2.Il Palagio
Paolo Lavezzini's one-star room with deep Super Tuscan verticals. Reserve weeks ahead for a serious red.
Il Palagio is the Four Seasons Firenze dining room, a one-star kitchen under Paolo Lavezzini set in a Renaissance palazzo with a garden terrace. Head sommelier Walter Meccia has built an almost entirely Italian list that leans hard into the Super Tuscans, with deep verticals of Sassicaia, Ornellaia, Masseto, Solaia and Tignanello to drink alongside Lavezzini's tortelli and his Italian-Brazilian cooking. This is the booking for a couple who want a recognisable great Tuscan bottle in a grand hotel room rather than a treasure hunt. Plan on 150 euro and up before wine. Reserve two to three weeks ahead, tell Meccia your budget, and let him pull a vertical to taste.
Book on the Four Seasons site; ask Walter Meccia for a Super Tuscan vertical.
3.Borgo San Jacopo
The Lungarno Collection's one-star over the Ponte Vecchio, terrace tables and a polished list. Book it for the view and the cellar.
Borgo San Jacopo is the Lungarno Collection's one-star room on the Oltrarno bank, with a small terrace looking straight up the Arno to the Ponte Vecchio. The kitchen cooks refined Tuscan, and the cellar follows it, strong across Tuscany and the rest of Italy with enough French and Champagne to round out a celebration. This is the romantic booking on the list, the room for a couple who want a serious bottle and the best river view in the city. Plan on 130 euro and up before wine. Reserve three to four weeks ahead for a terrace table, say you are celebrating, and let the floor match a Brunello to the menu.
Book on the Lungarno site; request a terrace table and ask the floor for a Tuscan red.
4.Ora d'Aria
Marco Stabile's central room with a smart, Tuscany-led list. Pencil it in for modern cooking and a clever pour.
Ora d'Aria sits a few steps from the Uffizi on Via dei Georgofili, Marco Stabile's modern Tuscan room and one of the city's better wine-led tables away from the hotels. The list is built around Tuscany and the rest of Italy, deep enough to reward a wine-led night but priced with more restraint than the grand rooms, which makes it the connoisseur's pick for a couple who want genuinely good bottles without a landmark-cellar bill. Plan on an upper-mid spend before wine. Reserve a week or two ahead, tell the floor what you are eating and what you want to spend, and let them steer you to something interesting and well-priced.
Book on the Ora d'Aria site; ask for the best-value Tuscan bottle on the list.
5.Osteria dell'Enoteca
An Oltrarno osteria built around the bottle, with a deep Tuscan and Italian cellar. Settle in for a wine-led night.
Osteria dell'Enoteca is a wine-first room on Via Romana in the Oltrarno, the kind of place where the list comes before the menu and the staff treat a Chianti Classico vertical as the point of the evening. The cellar runs deep through Tuscany and the rest of Italy, with a by-the-glass program wide enough to taste your way across the region in a sitting. This is the booking for a small group who want to drink seriously in a relaxed room rather than a starched dining room. Plan on a mid-to-upper spend before wine. Reserve a week ahead, sit where you can talk, and let the floor open a few Sangiovese to compare.
Book direct; ask the floor to line up a few Sangiovese by the glass.
6.Gucci Osteria da Massimo Bottura
Karime Lopez's one-star in the Gucci Garden with an international cellar. Try it once for the pairing.
Gucci Osteria sits on the Piazza della Signoria inside the Gucci Garden, a one-star room run by Karime Lopez under Massimo Bottura's name and one of the most distinctive cellars in the city. The list ranges far beyond Tuscany, with serious French, German and global bottles chosen to drink with Lopez's playful, well-travelled cooking, and a pairing program built to surprise rather than reassure. This is the booking for a wine drinker who wants something off the Tuscan script in a buzzy, design-led room. Plan on an upper spend before wine. Reserve three to four weeks ahead, take the pairing if you can, and ask the floor for the most unexpected bottle.
Book on the Gucci Osteria site; take the pairing and ask for the off-script bottle.
7.Il Santo Bevitore
A buzzy Oltrarno room with a characterful, terroir-led list and a wine bar next door. Worth the trip for the by-the-glass.
Il Santo Bevitore on Via di Santo Spirito has been the Oltrarno's smart-casual benchmark for two decades, a warm, low-lit room with a list that favours small Tuscan growers and characterful Italian bottles over big names. Its wine bar next door, Santino, lets you taste before you commit, and the by-the-glass program is one of the most thoughtful in the city. This is the booking for a couple who want excellent Tuscan cooking and a clever, fairly priced bottle in a room with genuine energy. Plan on a mid spend before wine. Reserve a week ahead, start with a glass at Santino, and let the floor pick a grower bottle.
Book direct; warm up with a glass at Santino, then ask for a grower bottle.
Avoid for a wine night
Name on the bottle, not on the list
All'Antico Vinaio. The Via dei Neri legend is the best sandwich in Florence and a fine glass of house red, but it is a schiacciata counter, not a cellar. Eat one standing up, then keep your wine night for one of the rooms above.
Golden View Open Bar. The Arno-side room has the view and a serviceable list, but it is built for turnover and a sunset Aperol rather than a serious bottle. Go for the panorama and an aperitivo, and drink your good wine across the river at Borgo San Jacopo.
How to drink well in Florence
Name a region and a number and let the floor work inside it; at Pinchiorri, Il Palagio and Borgo San Jacopo that conversation reliably turns up a better, often older bottle than the label you would have reached for, and all three are deep enough to pull aged Tuscan and French verticals on request. Book the landmark rooms three to four weeks ahead through their own sites, where the best weekend and terrace tables go first. For anything rare at Pinchiorri, say so when you book so the bottle is confirmed and standing up before you sit down.
The value-minded end, Ora d'Aria, Osteria dell'Enoteca and Il Santo Bevitore, rewards telling the floor what you are eating and what you want to spend and letting them find the grower bottle off-list. If Tuscany is driving the night, lean into Sangiovese and the Super Tuscans; if you want a change, Gucci Osteria's list travels furthest. And wherever you go, if you are celebrating, say so when you book so the room can make a night of it.
Frequently asked
Which Florence restaurant has the best wine list?
Enoteca Pinchiorri on Via Ghibellina holds our top spot, and few cellars anywhere rival it. The room carries past 60,000 bottles and roughly 4,000 labels from 19 countries, with old vintages of Petrus, Mouton-Rothschild and Romanee-Conti, and a Wine Spectator Grand Award. Head sommelier Alessandro Tomberli's team will pull an aged Tuscan or Burgundian bottle to drink with the three-star tasting menu. Plan on 300 euro and up before wine, reserve three to four weeks ahead, and name a region and a budget so the floor can open the cellar for you.
Where can I drink the best Super Tuscans in Florence?
Il Palagio at the Four Seasons is the room for Super Tuscans. Head sommelier Walter Meccia keeps deep verticals of Sassicaia, Ornellaia, Masseto, Solaia and Tignanello, an almost entirely Italian list built to drink with Paolo Lavezzini's one-star cooking. Tell Meccia your budget and he will pull a vertical to taste side by side. Reserve two to three weeks ahead, especially for a garden-terrace table in the warmer months.
Which Florence wine restaurant has the best view?
Borgo San Jacopo, the Lungarno Collection's one-star room on the Oltrarno bank, has a small terrace looking straight up the Arno to the Ponte Vecchio, the best river view of any serious wine room in the city. The cellar is strong across Tuscany and Italy with French and Champagne for a celebration. Reserve three to four weeks ahead for a terrace table and say if you are marking an occasion.
How much does a good bottle cost at Florence restaurants?
Plan on 50 to 110 euro for a genuinely good bottle at most of these rooms, with the ceiling far higher at Pinchiorri and Il Palagio, whose lists run into rare and aged territory. Ora d'Aria, Osteria dell'Enoteca and Il Santo Bevitore are the value-minded picks. The smart move everywhere is to set a number with the floor and let them find the grower bottle inside it; a good Florence list reads a budget as a brief rather than a ceiling.
Do you need a reservation for these Florence wine restaurants?
Yes for all of them, and well ahead for the destination rooms. Pinchiorri, Il Palagio, Borgo San Jacopo and Gucci Osteria release tables ahead and the best weekend and terrace tables go first, so book three to four weeks out. Ora d'Aria, Osteria dell'Enoteca and Il Santo Bevitore are easier but still worth reserving. For a rare or aged bottle at Pinchiorri, say so when you book so it is confirmed and ready.
Related rankings
More from RFK
Browse the full Florence dining guide, compare the best wine lists worldwide, see the Best Anniversary Restaurants in Florence 2026, or open the full RFK rankings index.
Restaurants for Kings is reader-supported. Some reservation links are affiliate links with OpenTable, Resy or Tock; we earn a small commission at no cost to you, and a link never buys a place on a ranking. Editorial scores and ranking order are independent of any commercial relationship. See our ranking methodology.