RFK Rankings · Reykjavik
Best Restaurants for a Birthday in Reykjavik 2026
Birthday · Reykjavik · 7 tables ranked · Updated May 2026
Compiled by the Restaurants for Kings editorial team · Published March 4, 2026 · Updated May 19, 2026 · Reviewed by Fredrik Filipsson, Editor-in-Chief · How we rank · Corrections
A birthday dinner asks for two things a tasting counter rarely gives: a table that fits the whole party and a room loud enough to sing happy birthday in. Reykjavik's centre is small, so the best birthday rooms are the buzzy downtown grills and seafood houses that seat eight or twenty without a fuss, plate a candle on request, and keep the night going. We have ranked seven, from the open-fire Grillmarket to one-star Dill for the milestone year, all currently open and all used to a celebration. The order weights the party first, then the cooking and the value.
1.Grillmarkadurinn
The Grillmarket: chef-driven open fire, lamb rack over birch, a big buzzy room that books eight to twenty. The birthday default.
Grillmarkadurinn, the Grillmarket, sits on Laekjargata in the centre and is the most reliable group birthday booking in Reykjavik. The kitchen cooks Icelandic produce over open flame, with a rack of lamb from Skagafjordur grilled over birch around ISK 9,400 and a tasting menu for the table. The room is big and lively, the bar pours well, and the floor handles parties of eight to twenty without losing the night's pace. A full dinner runs ISK 12,000 to 18,000 a head before drinks. Book a week or two ahead for a weekend, name the party size, and ask them to plate a candle for the birthday. It is the room that simply works for a group.
Reserve on the Grillmarkadurinn site one to two weeks ahead.
2.Fiskmarkadurinn
The Fish Market: chef Hrefna Saetran's seafood with Japanese technique, lively and group-friendly. A celebratory seafood table.
Fiskmarkadurinn, the Fish Market, is one of the older fine houses downtown and a natural birthday room for a table that wants fish. Chef Hrefna Saetran cooks Icelandic seafood with Japanese technique, a sushi bar and a charcoal grill running alongside a menu of plates built to share. The room is warm and busy on a weekend, which suits a celebration, and the kitchen is comfortable with a group ordering across the table. Expect ISK 12,000 to 16,000 a head before drinks. Book one to two weeks ahead, ask for a larger table, and let the kitchen send a tasting selection so the party tries the range. It is the seafood answer to Grillmarket next door.
Reserve on the Fiskmarkadurinn site one to two weeks ahead.
3.Apotek
Apotek Kitchen + Bar in a historic former pharmacy; a share-plate menu built for groups, central and festive. Easy to book.
Apotek Kitchen + Bar occupies a historic former pharmacy on Austurstraeti, central location every guest can walk to, and its share-plate menu is built for a table rather than a couple. The cocktail bar at the front sets a festive tone, the plates run from Icelandic lamb and fish to lighter small dishes, and the room takes a birthday group easily. A dinner lands around ISK 9,000 to 14,000 a head before drinks, which keeps it the affordable centre-of-town option. Book three to seven days ahead, start with cocktails at the bar, and have the kitchen send a spread of plates for the table to graze. It is the relaxed, central birthday that does not break the budget.
Reserve on the Apotek site three to seven days ahead.
4.Kol
A modern grill with a serious cocktail bar, robust steaks, lamb and fish in a lively festive room. A confident group choice.
Kol is a modern downtown grill with one of the better cocktail programmes in the city and a kitchen that cooks robust mains: steaks, lamb and fish off the grill, plated to share or solo. The room is lively and a little glossy, which reads as an occasion without tipping into formal, and the bar gives a party somewhere to gather before the table is ready. A dinner runs ISK 11,000 to 16,000 a head before drinks. Kol does not have its own RFK profile yet, so the link points to the wider Reykjavik dining guide. Book a week ahead for a weekend, start at the bar, and ask for a table set away from the door so the group can settle in.
Reserve on the Kol site about a week ahead.
5.Sumac
Levantine technique on Icelandic produce, a MICHELIN Bib Gourmand, sharing plates in a stylish warm room. The flavourful group table.
Sumac on Laugavegur cooks Levantine and Lebanese technique over Icelandic produce, and has held a MICHELIN Bib Gourmand since 2019 across six editions of the guide. The menu is built on sharing plates, mezze through to grilled mains, which makes it one of the best birthday tables in the city for a group that likes to pass dishes around. The room is stylish and warm, the spicing is generous, and a dinner runs ISK 9,000 to 13,000 a head before drinks, strong value for the recognition. Book a week ahead for a weekend, order the spread for the table, and let the kitchen lead on the mezze. It is the most interesting cooking at this price in town.
Reserve on the Sumac site about a week ahead.
6.Dill
Gunnar Karl Gislason's one-star New Nordic tasting, Iceland's first star; the milestone birthday for a small, serious party.
Dill on Hverfisgata is the milestone-birthday room, the place for the year that deserves the cooking rather than the crowd. Chef Gunnar Karl Gislason holds one MICHELIN star, Iceland's first when it was awarded in 2017, and serves a New Nordic tasting built on Icelandic provenance around ISK 27,500 with an optional wine pairing. The dining room is small and intimate, so it suits a party of two to six rather than a loud table of fifteen, and the meal is an event in its own right. Book three to four weeks ahead for a weekend seating, take the pairing, and tell them it is a birthday so the kitchen can mark the occasion within the tasting.
Reserve on the Dill site three to four weeks ahead.
7.Sjavargrillid
A downtown seafood grill in a warm wood-lined room, generous Icelandic plates; a cosy, celebratory backup. Worth booking.
Sjavargrillid, the Seafood Grill, sits downtown in a warm, wood-lined room that lends itself to a celebration without the buzz of the bigger grills. The kitchen cooks Icelandic seafood and lamb, often grilled, with generous plating and a tasting menu for a table that wants the kitchen to lead. It is the cosier birthday choice for a party of four to eight who want a warm room over a loud one, and a dinner runs ISK 10,000 to 15,000 a head before drinks. Book a week ahead, ask for the tasting if the group is happy to share courses, and flag the birthday so they can bring out a candle. It rounds out the list as the snug, dependable option.
Reserve on the Sjavargrillid site about a week ahead.
Avoid for a birthday
Brilliant rooms, wrong for a party
OX. The one-MICHELIN-star counter is an eleven-seat chef's table tucked behind Sumac, a single nightly seating built for a quiet two. There is no way to book it for a group and no room to toast, so a birthday party would split the table or be turned away. Save it for an intimate dinner of two, not a birthday party of ten.
Moss. The destination tasting room at the Retreat by the Blue Lagoon is a long drive from the city, a slow multi-course evening for two who want the cooking in silence. It is a wonderful meal and the wrong shape for a group birthday, which wants a table you can talk across rather than a hushed counter an hour out of town.
Reykjavik's small tasting counters in general, OX above all, seat two well and ten not at all. If the birthday is a party rather than a milestone for one or two, skip the counters and book one of the downtown group rooms ranked above, where the floor expects a large table and a candle.
Reservation strategy for a Reykjavik birthday
Reykjavik's centre is compact, so the group rooms book up fast on a Friday or Saturday. For a party of six or more, give Grillmarket, the Fish Market and Apotek one to two weeks, and give one-star Dill three to four weeks for its small dining room. Most take bookings through their own sites or by phone. When you reserve, name the party size and say it is a birthday, then ask for a long table or a corner away from the door so the group can settle in rather than being split across the floor.
Ask about a cake or a candle at booking, not on the night, because the group rooms can usually plate a dessert with a candle or hold a cake you bring, sometimes for a small plating fee. Drinks carry a steep markup in Iceland, so set a wine plan or lean on the cocktail bars at Apotek and Kol to open the evening. Reykjavik dines a little earlier than the Mediterranean cities, so an 19:30 to 20:00 booking gives the party a full, warm room. The detail you sort in advance is what keeps the night moving on it.
Frequently asked
What is the best restaurant for a birthday in Reykjavik?
Grillmarket on Laekjargata is the most reliable group birthday booking downtown. The chef-driven open-fire kitchen does lamb rack from Skagafjordur over birch and other Icelandic mains, the room is big and buzzy, and it takes parties of eight to twenty without fuss. Expect ISK 12,000 to 18,000 a head before drinks. Reserve a week or two ahead for a Friday or Saturday and tell them it is a birthday.
Where can a large group celebrate a birthday in Reykjavik?
Grillmarket, the Fish Market and Apotek all take larger parties downtown. Grillmarket seats eight to twenty in a lively room, the Fish Market does sharing-friendly Icelandic seafood, and Apotek runs a share-plate menu built for a table. All three sit within a few blocks of the centre, so guests can walk in. Book one to two weeks ahead and ask for a long table or a private corner.
How much does a birthday dinner cost in Reykjavik?
Plan on ISK 9,000 to 18,000 a head before drinks at the group rooms, and ISK 27,500 plus pairing at one-star Dill. Apotek and Sumac sit at the lower end near ISK 9,000 to 14,000, Grillmarket and the Fish Market run ISK 12,000 upward, and Dill's tasting is the milestone splurge. Drinks move the bill most in Reykjavik, where wine carries a steep markup.
Which Reykjavik restaurant is best for a milestone birthday?
Dill on Hverfisgata is the milestone choice. Chef Gunnar Karl Gislason holds one MICHELIN star, Iceland's first, awarded in 2017, and cooks a New Nordic tasting around ISK 27,500 with an optional pairing. The room is small, so it suits a party of two to six who want the cooking rather than a loud table. Book three to four weeks ahead for a weekend seating.
Can you get a birthday cake at Reykjavik restaurants?
Most of the group rooms will handle a cake or a candle if you ask at booking. Grillmarket, the Fish Market, Apotek and Sjavargrillid are used to birthday tables and can plate a dessert with a candle or store a cake you bring. Flag it when you reserve, not on the night, and ask whether they charge a plating fee. The tasting rooms are less flexible on outside cake.
Do I need to book ahead for a birthday in Reykjavik?
Yes, especially for a weekend or a larger group. The downtown group rooms want one to two weeks for a Friday or Saturday table of six or more, and Dill wants three to four weeks for its small dining room. Reserve through each restaurant's own site or by phone, name the party size, and say it is a birthday so they can seat you well.
Related rankings
More from RFK
Browse the full Reykjavik dining guide, see the best birthday tables worldwide, compare fine dining worldwide, or open the full RFK rankings index.
Restaurants for Kings is reader-supported. Some reservation links are affiliate links with OpenTable, Resy or Tock; we earn a small commission at no cost to you, and a link never buys a place on a ranking. Editorial scores and ranking order are independent of any commercial relationship. See our ranking methodology.