Martha's Vineyard’s Greatest Tables
5 restaurants listedGet the complete Martha's Vineyard dining guide.
New openings, reservation tips, and editor picks — updated quarterly. Free to join.
$ under $40 · $$ $40–$80 · $$$ $80–$150 · $$$$ $150+ per person
Best for First Date in Martha's Vineyard
Best for Business Dinner in Martha's Vineyard
The Top 5 Martha's Vineyard Restaurants
The Terrace at The Charlotte Inn
The Terrace occupies a converted Victorian carriage house at 27 South Summer Street in the heart of Edgartown's historic whaling district - one block off Main Street, three blocks from Edgartown Harbor's working ferry slip and the Edgartown Lighthouse promenade - and has held the seat as the island's only Relais and Chateaux property since The Charlotte Inn earned the credential. The dining room runs about sixty covers across a series of intimate Victorian parlors with original wide-plank hardwood, careful low-light through dinner service, working antique furnishings sourced from the inn's three-decade collection, period New England portraits and a deliberate carriage-house-with-enclosed-garden palette that reads as a working Relais and Chateaux destination rather than a generic seasonal inn restaurant. An enclosed garden terrace adds about twenty covers in the warmer months - string-lit, hedged, the most-photographed proposal setting on the island.
State Road Restaurant
State Road Restaurant occupies a converted island-vernacular farmhouse at 688 State Road in West Tisbury - the working agricultural up-island village three miles inland of the working Vineyard Haven harbor, surrounded by the West Tisbury farm belt, two minutes' drive from the working Allen Farm and three minutes from the working West Tisbury Farmers Market - and has held the seat as the island's reference farm-to-table chef-driven destination since opening in 2009. The dining room runs about ninety covers across a deliberate warm-modern parlor with working barn-board ceilings, careful exposed-stone fireplace, warm low light through dinner service, hardwood floors, working hand-thrown pottery on the tables and a deliberate working island-farmhouse palette that reads as a working chef-driven kitchen rather than a Steamship-Authority-village seasonal operation. The 2026 James Beard semifinalist nod for Outstanding Hospitality places the room in a national conversation few island restaurants enter.
Detente
Detente occupies an intimate wine-cellar storefront at 15 Winter Street in Edgartown's Nevin Square - a converted nineteenth-century captain's-house courtyard two blocks off Main Street, one block from the working Edgartown Harbor waterfront and three blocks from the Edgartown Lighthouse promenade - and has held the seat as the island's reference modern-seasonal-with-wine-programme bistro destination for nearly two decades. The dining room runs about fifty covers across a deliberate intimate wine-cellar parlor with working exposed-brick walls, warm low light through dinner service, careful hardwood floors, working antique wine racks along the walls and a deliberate modern-seasonal-bistro palette that reads as a working refined fine-dining destination rather than a touristic Main Street operation. The Nevin Square courtyard setting gives the room a working hidden-gem character that long-time Edgartown summer regulars know to seek out.
Alchemy Bistro & Bar
Alchemy Bistro & Bar occupies a converted whaling-captain's-house storefront at 71 Main Street in the heart of Edgartown - the working main-street commercial spine, two blocks from the Edgartown Harbor ferry slip and three blocks from the Edgartown Lighthouse - and has held the seat as Edgartown's reference chef-driven New American since opening in 1999. The dining room runs about a hundred covers across a deliberate two-floor configuration with working hardwood floors, careful warm low light through dinner service, a working main-floor bar that anchors the room and a deliberate modern-bistro palette that reads as a working Edgartown chef-driven institution rather than a seasonal tourist operation. Executive Chef Christopher Stam - drawing on island roots and a global culinary career - has driven the kitchen's working seasonal direction.
19 Raw Oyster Bar
19 Raw Oyster Bar occupies a converted Edgartown storefront at 19 Church Street - just off Main Street, two blocks from the Edgartown Harbor ferry slip and three blocks from the Edgartown Lighthouse promenade - and has held the seat as the island's reference modern raw-bar destination since opening. The dining room runs about eighty covers across a deliberate compact two-floor configuration with a working raw-bar counter at the front of the house, careful warm low light through dinner service, working hardwood floors, deliberate exposed-brick accent walls and a deliberate modern-seafood-bar palette that reads as a working chef-driven raw-bar room rather than a generic Main Street tourist operation. The room sits atop the same operator's 19 Prime Steakhouse - a Church Street prime-cut sister room with the working steakhouse format.