The Restaurant
Molly's Restaurant & Bar has occupied a deep storefront at 43 South Main Street in Hanover since 1985, three blocks south of the Dartmouth Green on the same row that holds the local stationer, the long-running camera shop, and a bookstore. The room itself is the warm Hanover bistro format — exposed brick, dark wood, generously spaced tables, an open kitchen at the back with a visible stone pizza oven, and a long L-shaped bar near the entrance that takes walk-in dining. About a hundred and twenty covers across the main room, the bar, and a small mezzanine that takes private parties of up to twenty.
The kitchen runs a deliberately broad American-bistro menu — wood-fired pizzas (the margherita, the prosciutto-and-arugula, the four-cheese, and a rotating chef's special); a wood-grilled steak with herb butter and house frites; a salmon with maple-and-Dijon glaze; a Caesar salad with white-anchovy dressing that the regulars order without looking at the menu; a generous pasta programme including a lobster-and-butter ravioli that the room is genuinely known for; and a brunch-meets-lunch programme on weekends that brings the Dartmouth-parents-weekend crowd reliably through the door. The dessert case at the back runs a chocolate-tartufo and a maple crème brûlée that handles the candle-and-singing moment for a birthday party with no friction.
The beer list is solid (about twenty drafts plus a useful bottle programme), the wine list is short but careful (about fifty bottles, biased toward California and Italy), and the cocktail programme is the unfussy classic-and-house-signature format. Service is paced at the friendly-Hanover-veteran tempo — many of the front-of-house team have worked the room for more than a decade — and the kitchen handles a twelve-top without strain. Generations of Dartmouth graduates have brought their parents, then their spouses, then their children, then their alumni-reunion classmates here. The room earns its landmark status by being exactly the same thing every year, consistently and well.
Why This Is Hanover’s Birthday Pick
For a Hanover birthday — particularly a Dartmouth-student birthday, a faculty birthday, or a local family birthday with mixed generations at the table — Molly's hits the brief precisely. The menu has an obvious answer for every diner at the table (pizza for the younger, the wood-grilled steak for the older, the Caesar for the regulars, the ravioli for the pasta person). The room handles a party of ten without strain on the mezzanine. The dessert case absorbs the candle moment without requiring elaborate staging. And the room's four-decade Hanover identity makes the celebration feel embedded in the town rather than parked in a chain.
Community Poll
What is the best occasion for Molly's Restaurant & Bar?
Join free to vote and leave a review.
Leave a Review
Registered members get published by default; guest reviews are moderated first.