RFK Rankings · Nantucket
Best Restaurants for Solo Dining in Nantucket 2026
Solo Dining · Nantucket · 6 tables ranked · Updated June 2026
Compiled by the Restaurants for Kings editorial team · Published June 15, 2026 · Updated June 15, 2026 · Reviewed by Fredrik Filipsson, Editor-in-Chief · How we rank · Corrections
Oysters shucked to order along a glass-walled bar at the end of Straight Wharf, the boats coming in beyond the rail: that is CRU, and it is one of the easiest great meals to eat alone on Nantucket. The island's table runs on the group, the share-house dinner and the long celebration out at the Wauwinet, and that is part of its character. But the wharves and the town centre hold a strong run of counters and bars where a single cover is the norm: raw bars, sushi counters, chef's bars and bistro stools. A solo traveller off the ferry, or a single diner who simply wants a good dinner, can do very well by taking a seat at the bar. These six rooms, ranked, are where eating by yourself on Nantucket is a pleasure rather than a compromise.
1.CRU Oyster Bar
Erin Zircher's harbor oyster bar, oysters and a buttered lobster roll; the best solo seat on the water. Sit at the bar.
CRU sits at the end of Straight Wharf on Nantucket harbor, a glass-walled oyster bar open from mid-May to mid-October since 2013. Executive chef Erin Zircher, a partner along with Jane Stoddard and Carlos Hidalgo, runs a raw bar that is the island's best seat for one: a stool at the bar, a dozen oysters, and the warm, buttered lobster roll that made the room's name. The harbor is the view and the boats are the show, which is company enough for a solo diner. CRU draws a crowd, so a single seat at the raw bar early is the move. Walk up for a raw-bar stool at opening or in the late afternoon, order oysters and the lobster roll, and watch the harbor.
Walk up for a raw-bar stool at opening; reservations cover tables, not the bar.
2.The Nautilus
Liam Mackey's coastal-Asian small plates with a chef's bar kept for walk-ins; the island's most fun solo seat. Grab a bar stool.
The Nautilus has run since 2014 on Lower Pearl Street, a tiny room of fewer than fifty seats from executive chef Liam Mackey. The cooking is New England coastal meets Asian and global street food, served as small plates built to share, and the room keeps both a main bar and a chef's bar for walk-ins. That is the gift for a solo diner: reservations open seven days out and vanish fast, but a single cover can usually find a first-come seat at the bar. Eaten this way, the place is the most fun table for one on the island. Arrive when the doors open, take a chef's-bar stool, and order the bao and whatever crudo is running that night.
Main-bar and chef's-bar seats are first-come; arrive at opening to claim one.
3.Bar Yoshi
The waterfront sushi bar that replaced 25-year Sushi by Yoshi, open late; a natural solo seat. Sit at the bar.
Bar Yoshi sits on Old South Wharf, the waterfront successor to Sushi by Yoshi, a Nantucket fixture for more than twenty-five years. The room is small, with direct views into the kitchen and a counter that runs late, open through the afternoon into the early hours of the morning. Sushi at a bar is solo dining at its most natural: a single diner orders nigiri, rolls, dumplings and ceviche piece by piece and watches the knives. It is also one of the few island kitchens serving past midnight, which makes it the late solo seat as well. Take a seat at the bar, order nigiri and a few dumplings, and stay as long as you like.
Walk in for a counter seat; the kitchen runs late when most rooms have closed.
4.Straight Wharf
Gabriel Frasca's harborside landmark keeps a bar and raw bar for one; the polished solo seat on the water. Book the bar.
Straight Wharf has been a Nantucket institution since the 1970s, on a deck right over the harbor, with Gabriel Frasca as executive chef since 2006. The dining room is a special-occasion seafood room, but the bar and its raw bar are where a solo diner belongs: oysters and crudo, a glass of white, and the boats coming in beyond the rail. It is the most polished harborside seat for one on the island, the kitchen serious and the setting hard to beat at sunset. A single cover at the bar gets the view and the kitchen without the formality of the dining room. Book a bar seat for the early evening, order from the raw bar, and time it to the light.
Book a bar seat on Resy for the early evening; the bar takes a single cover well.
5.Òran Mór
Edwin Claflin's upstairs fine-dining room with a daily-changing menu and a small bar; the quiet solo splurge in town. Reserve the bar.
Òran Mór occupies an intimate upstairs room at 2 South Beach Street, a Nantucket fine-dining fixture for more than twenty years, where chef and owner Edwin Claflin cooks a refined, daily-changing New American menu built around the island's seafood and what the boats and farms bring in. It is the quiet fine-dining room on this list, away from the wharf crowds, and the small bar is the seat for a solo diner who wants a serious dinner without a table for one in a celebration room. Claflin will tailor a meal around what you want, which suits a single cover well. Reserve a bar seat, ask the kitchen to build the evening, and take the wine by the glass so the meal stays yours.
Reserve a bar seat on the Òran Mór site; the room is small, so book ahead.
6.The Boarding House
A Federal Street fixture whose Boho bar and patio run the Pearl's menu; an easy solo seat. Take a bar seat.
The Boarding House has anchored 12 Federal Street since the 1990s, a below-grade dining room with a street-level bar and patio known as the Boho. For 2026 the bar and patio run the menu of its sibling upstairs, The Pearl, a coastal Asian-fusion kitchen heavy on raw bar and wok cooking, with an off-menu burger kept just for the Boho. That bar and patio are the solo seat: a single cover can sit streetside, order from the raw bar and a wok dish, and watch the town go by. It is one of the easier good seats for one in the centre of town. Take a seat at the Boho bar, order oysters and the lobster lo mein, and the burger if you know to ask.
Take a first-come seat at the Boho bar or patio; the dining room books separately.
Avoid for solo dining
Right island, wrong format
Toppers at the Wauwinet. The Relais & Châteaux dining room is a destination, but reaching it means a drive or the hotel launch out to the Wauwinet, and the whole evening is built as a special-occasion production for two or a group. A solo diner faces a long journey for a room pitched at celebration. Save it for an anniversary with company.
Galley Beach. The Cliffside sunset room is one of the island's prettiest, and that is the point: it is a scene built for groups and celebrations, with prices to match. A single cover pays for the view and the buzz at a table designed for a party. Bring people and book it for the sunset.
Reservation strategy for solo dining in Nantucket
Two habits cover the island, and the season frames both: most of these rooms open from mid-May to mid-October, and June through August is the crush. The booked rooms want a reservation well ahead in high summer: Straight Wharf and Òran Mór take bookings, and a single cover asking for a bar seat a week or two out will usually get one. Choose a weeknight over a weekend, ask for a seat at the bar or raw bar where it exists, and request the wine by the glass so a solo evening stays your own.
The bars and counters are the opposite discipline. The Nautilus holds chef's-bar and main-bar seats for walk-ins, CRU keeps raw-bar stools that turn over fast, and Bar Yoshi runs a sushi counter late into the night. Go right at opening or after the first seating, take the bar rather than a table, and order the one or two dishes each room is known for. Eaten this way, a table for one on Nantucket never feels like a compromise.
Frequently asked
What is the best restaurant for solo dining on Nantucket?
CRU is the top pick. The glass-walled oyster bar at the end of Straight Wharf, run by executive chef Erin Zircher, is the island's best seat for one: a stool at the raw bar, a dozen oysters, and the warm, buttered lobster roll that made its name, with the harbor as the view. It opens mid-May to mid-October and draws a crowd, so take a raw-bar seat early. Walk up at opening or in the late afternoon.
Where can you eat alone at a counter or bar on Nantucket?
Nantucket is full of good counters and bars for one. CRU runs a harbor raw bar, The Nautilus keeps a chef's bar and main bar for walk-ins, and Bar Yoshi serves sushi at a waterfront counter on Old South Wharf. Straight Wharf holds a bar and raw bar over the harbor, and The Boarding House seats a single cover at its Boho bar. Ask for a counter or bar seat rather than a table whenever the room offers one.
How much does solo dining cost on Nantucket?
Anywhere from about $35 to $120 a head before drinks, and this is an expensive island. Straight Wharf and Òran Mór are the upper-end rooms, while CRU, The Nautilus, Bar Yoshi and The Boarding House let a single diner eat well at the bar for $40 to $90. Most rooms are a la carte at the bar, so a solo cover controls the length and the bill. Eat oysters and small plates rather than a full tasting to keep it in check.
Can you walk in for solo dining on Nantucket?
Often, yes, at the bars, and a single seat is easier to place than a two-top in high season. The Nautilus keeps chef's-bar seats for walk-ins, CRU's raw-bar stools turn over, and Bar Yoshi runs late. Straight Wharf and Òran Mór want a reservation. Go right at opening or after the first seating, sit at the bar, and order the dish each room is known for. Weeknights are easiest across the board.
Is Nantucket good for eating alone?
It is, in season, more than its share-house reputation suggests. Most rooms run from mid-May to mid-October, and the wharves and town centre hold a strong run of raw bars, sushi counters and chef's bars where a table for one is unremarkable. A single diner can eat oysters at CRU, small plates at The Nautilus and sushi at Bar Yoshi within a short walk of each other. Sit at the bar, order a la carte, and you will eat very well by yourself here.
Related rankings
More from RFK
Browse the full Nantucket dining guide, see the best solo dining tables worldwide, compare the best seafood restaurants worldwide, or open the full RFK rankings index.
Restaurants for Kings is reader-supported. Some reservation links are affiliate links with OpenTable, Resy or Tock; we earn a small commission at no cost to you, and a link never buys a place on a ranking. Editorial scores and ranking order are independent of any commercial relationship. See our ranking methodology.