The Restaurant
Polo Grill anchors the southwest corner of Utica Square - the open-air luxury retail complex three miles southeast of downtown Tulsa that has served as the city's senior commercial address since 1952. Chef-proprietor Robert Merrifield opened Polo Grill in 1983 and has operated the room continuously across four decades, an unusually durable tenure that has made the restaurant the longest-running fine-dining address in Oklahoma and the only restaurant in the state to hold both the DiRoNA (Distinguished Restaurants of North America) designation and the AAA Four Diamond rating. The dining room seats approximately one hundred across a softly lit interior of polished wood, leather-and-suede banquettes, and a careful gallery of equestrian art - the visual register reads as a classical American grill of the Lutece-and-21-Club generation.
The kitchen programme is classical American fine dining with deliberate sourcing seriousness - USDA Prime steaks dry-aged in-house, seasonal seafood flown in from coastal sources, and a careful Oklahoma-and-regional produce programme that anchors the seasonal menu rotations. Signature dishes across Merrifield's four decades have included the tableside Caesar salad prepared from a 1980s house recipe, the Steak Diane finished tableside with a brandy reduction, the bone-in ribeye dry-aged twenty-eight days, the pan-seared Chilean sea bass with a citrus beurre blanc, the rack of New Zealand lamb with a rosemary jus, and a dessert programme that includes Polo Grill's signature Grand Marnier souffle prepared to order. The Tenderloin Hatch Chile Queso starter and the Roasted Garlic Parmesan Bread for Two have anchored the menu's starter section since the 1990s.
The wine programme is Oklahoma's senior structural achievement: Polo Grill has held Wine Spectator's Best of Award of Excellence since 2000, running about nine hundred references with deliberate weight in California cabernet, serious Bordeaux progression, a careful Italian section, and a substantial Champagne and dessert-wine programme. The careful staff training - many servers have been at Polo Grill for fifteen to twenty-five years - means the room delivers the kind of practised discretion that supports senior business-dinner conversations across decades.
Why This Is Tulsa’s Close a Deal Pick
For closing a deal in Tulsa, Polo Grill is the city's structurally obvious answer. The forty-year operational track record under chef-proprietor Merrifield means every senior Tulsa principal has eaten in this room across multiple decades. The DiRoNA designation and the AAA Four Diamond rating signal the kind of national-recognition register that allows a visiting client to confirm the room's seriousness before arrival. The 9.1 ambience score reflects deliberate visual restraint: the polished wood and leather-and-suede interior never competes with the conversation, the equestrian art register reads correctly as classical American business dining, and the careful table spacing means a private discussion stays private. The Utica Square address - three miles southeast of downtown but only a six-minute drive from the BOK Center and the Tulsa Convention Center - makes Polo Grill the structurally obvious pairing for a senior business evening.
Leave a Review
Registered members get published by default; guest reviews are moderated first.