Creative Italian with an Arizona twist — wood-fired dishes and house pasta in a convivial room that makes first dates comfortable without feeling predictable.
Twisted Italian at 9940 W Happy Valley Pkwy opened in 2010 and has spent the intervening years building the kind of neighbourhood reputation that chain restaurants spend enormous marketing budgets trying to replicate and never quite achieve. The restaurant is independently owned and operated, which in practice means that the menu decisions are made by people who will be cooking the food and serving the tables rather than by a committee in a corporate office in another state. This distinction matters in ways that are immediately apparent.
The menu is Italian in foundation, creatively inflected in execution. House-made pasta, lasagna built to order with house Italian sausage and a house meat sauce, and a wood-fired component that gives the cooking depth and a smoky edge absent from conventional Italian-American restaurants. The Chicago and Midwest influences — authentic Italian beef sandwiches, house-made pierogies, walleye on Fridays — add unexpected dimensions that reflect the owners' culinary history without disrupting the Italian framework. A full bar accompanies the food, and the gluten-free pasta and ravioli options accommodate the dietary preferences that Italian menus sometimes overlook.
The room at Twisted Italian is and modern in the way that a well-maintained independently-owned neighbourhood Italian should be: not trying to be anything other than a good restaurant in a good neighbourhood, but doing it with enough personality to feel specific rather than generic. The noise level is convivial. The service is experienced. The price point is fair in a way that makes the decision to return easy to justify.
Creative Italian is a reliable first-date format because the cuisine is familiar enough that neither party needs to navigate unfamiliar food territory, but the Twisted Italian menu is distinctive enough that there are specific things to talk about. The wood-fired dishes provide a conversation anchor. The house pasta justifies the choice. And the price point removes the calculation that more expensive first-date venues introduce. Twisted Italian is the Peoria first-date restaurant that works because it is genuinely good without being intimidating about it.
Address
9940 W Happy Valley Pkwy, #1080, Peoria, AZ 85383
Cuisine
Italian — Creative
Hours
Tue–Thu 11:30am–8:30pm, Fri 11:30am–9pm
Price Per Person
$18–35 per person
Dress Code
Casual to smart casual
Reservations
Via OpenTable or direct
Note
Gluten-free pasta available
Best For
First Date
Cast your vote — which occasion does Twisted Italian serve best?
You must create a free account to vote and see results.
Join the community to read member reviews and submit your verdict for Twisted Italian.
Join Free →Back to all restaurants in Peoria, AZ — See the First Date occasion guide — Read our Arizona dining blog
Editor-picked alternatives by score, occasion, and cuisine.
If you like this room, our editors also rate these in the same city.