The Verdict
THE FOUR HORSEMEN holds a Michelin star in Williamsburg for the natural wine bar that James Murphy — the LCD Soundsystem founder whose parallel career as a wine obsessive predates his musical fame — opened with the conviction that natural wine deserved the same audience in New York that it had developed in Paris. The result is the most influential natural wine destination in the city: a bar whose list reflects Murphy's personal relationships with producers across France and the natural wine world.
The seasonal small plates menu at The Four Horsemen is built to complement the wine list's specific character: preparations whose acid, fat, and flavour balance are calibrated for the natural wines rather than for a conventional pairing programme. The kitchen's specific knowledge of what works with unfiltered, unfined, and minimally sulphured wines produces food that makes the wine better and wine that makes the food better.
One Michelin star in Williamsburg for a bar whose cultural context amplifies the wine programme's specific identity: the neighbourhood's music and creative community, whose appreciation for the craft and authenticity that natural wine communicates makes The Four Horsemen the gathering point whose identity extends beyond its address.
Why It Works for a First Date
The Four Horsemen's combination of James Murphy's cultural identity, the Williamsburg creative community, and the natural wine list's genuine producer knowledge creates the first date whose cultural substance extends beyond the meal. The Brooklyn neighbourhood extends the evening into the music and art community that surrounds the bar.
Also in New York City
Explore the full New York City restaurant guide. See our Impress Clients, First Date, and Close a Deal occasion guides for curated picks across Asia.