The Verdict
JULIANA'S is Patsy Grimaldi's return to the coal-fired pizza that he sold when he retired — the pizzaiolo who founded Grimaldi's under the Brooklyn Bridge selling the restaurant and his name, then emerging from retirement to open Juliana's in the same neighbourhood, reclaiming his technique under a new name. The coal-fired oven, the specific dough, and the preparation approach that Grimaldi developed across his career produce a pizza that the Brooklyn food community argues is superior to the establishment he left behind.
The coal-fired pizza at Juliana's communicates the same specific technique that made Grimaldi's famous: the 800-degree coal oven's specific heat distribution producing the char on the crust that gas cannot replicate, the San Marzano tomatoes, and the fresh mozzarella applied in the specific amounts that the crust's surface can carry.
The Old Fulton Street location provides the Brooklyn Bridge neighbourhood context that amplifies the rivalry: Grimaldi's visible blocks away, the bridge above both establishments, and the specific Brooklyn food community debate about which version of Patsy Grimaldi's technique is superior — the establishment or the return.
Why It Works for a First Date
The Juliana's story — Patsy Grimaldi reclaiming his technique under a new name to compete with the restaurant that bears his original name — gives the first date the most specific available Brooklyn pizza cultural narrative. The coal-fired pizza provides the substance. The rivalry provides the conversation.
Also in New York City
Explore the full New York City restaurant guide. See our Impress Clients, First Date, and Close a Deal occasion guides for curated picks across Asia.