Nantucket's Greatest Tables
15 restaurants listedGet the complete city dining guide.
New openings, reservation tips, and editor picks — updated quarterly. Free to join.
$ under $40 · $$ $40–$80 · $$$ $80–$150 · $$$$ $150+ per person
Best for First Date in Nantucket
Best for Business Dinner in Nantucket
Nantucket's Top 10
Topper's at The Wauwinet
The journey alone — a shuttle boat or a country road winding to the tip of the island — prepares you for what Topper's delivers. The Wauwinet is Nantucket's only Relais & Château property, and its restaurant earns that designation entirely on its own merits. Chef's butter-poached lobster spaghetti, pan-roasted bay scallops from the island's own waters, and a wine programme of some 2,000 bottles spanning rare verticals: this is the meal you tell people about. Book the window table if it's available. Arrive early enough for cocktails on the lawn as the sun falls over the bay.
Company of the Cauldron
A small red building on India Street, ivy on the windows, candles the only light. Company of the Cauldron has operated under a single rule since 1977: one menu, one seating, no substitutions. The menu changes nightly — you might have Beef Wellington, you might have pan-seared sea bass with island corn succotash, you might have precisely the meal you didn't know you needed. The prix fixe format runs around $165 per person, which, for this level of culinary conviction and romantic atmosphere, constitutes one of the island's fairest transactions.
Straight Wharf Restaurant
Straight Wharf has been the standard against which Nantucket's restaurant scene measures itself for five decades. Positioned at 6 Harbor Square where the wharf meets the water, the dining room's shingled walls and hurricane lamps frame a view that changes every season while the commitment to locally-sourced, hand-crafted cuisine remains constant. The menu rotates nightly based on market availability. Come for the harbour-facing back deck in summer; come for the intimate dining room in September when the light turns low and the island exhales.
The Pearl
The Pearl operates in a register entirely its own on this island of traditional New England cooking. At 12 Federal Street, chef-owner Seth Raynor built a reputation for creative cocktails and the kind of Asian-inflected seafood that provokes genuine excitement. The signature Nantucket Salt & Pepper Wok-Fried Lobster earned Travel & Leisure's World's Best Award designation — not hyperbole, but a fair assessment of what happens when an island lobster meets a serious wok. The Pearl also won Best Seafood Restaurant in All of New England from New England Travel & Life.
Galley Beach
The Silva family has owned Galley Beach since 1958, which on Nantucket counts as legacy. The restaurant sits at 54 Jefferson Avenue with sand genuinely underfoot on the beach terrace and sunset views across the water that no design budget could replicate. The cellar holds over 5,000 bottles. Dinner is a two-course prix fixe at $89 — seared halibut, butter-poached lobster, and whatever the market provided that morning. Book at least two weeks in advance during peak season. The sunset table is worth any inconvenience required to secure it.
CRU Oyster Bar
Since opening in May 2012 at 1 Straight Wharf, CRU has established itself as the island's most reliably excellent waterfront experience. The oysters are harvested from the surrounding waters and arrive at the bar with the salinity of Nantucket Sound still present. The raw bar extends to caviar and premier seafood medley; the kitchen handles halibut, lobster, and chowder with the confidence of a restaurant that knows its audience. Two bars ensure that the inevitable wait for a table is pleasantly spent.
Via Mare
Via Mare occupies a wood-panelled room at 17 Broad Street inside Greydon House, a boutique hotel designed by Roman and Williams — the firm responsible for the Ace Hotel New York and The Standard, High Line. The concept draws from Venice's bacaro tradition of small-plate dining and spirited drinking in neighbourhood taverns. The result is the island's most urbane dining experience: homemade bread, impeccable mussels, a natural wine list that rewards exploration, and service calibrated to the room's intelligence.
Brant Point Grill
Within the White Elephant Hotel, Brant Point Grill holds a Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence and a prime position on the harbour-front veranda. The kitchen handles prime steaks and fresh seafood with equal confidence, and the room carries a civilised maritime aesthetic that rewards arriving dressed for the occasion. Breakfast and lunch service is available for hotel guests; dinner is the event.
The Boarding House
One of Nantucket Town's most dependable dinner institutions, The Boarding House combines sophisticated nautical warmth — low lighting, exposed brick, a buzzy bar — with a menu that pulls from the island's best seasonal producers. The cocktail programme is taken seriously. The kitchen understands the difference between a plate and an experience. For a birthday dinner that doesn't demand the formality of Topper's, this is where to book.
Oran Mor
Oran Mor rewards those who climb the stairs of its historic North Wharf building with some of the most thoughtful seasonal cooking on the island. The second-floor setting creates a natural intimacy that the ground-floor tourist trade cannot provide. The menu evolves with Nantucket's seasons, anchored by whatever arrives freshest from farm and harbour. For a business dinner requiring real conversation and impeccable discretion, Oran Mor provides exactly the room for it.
The Nantucket Dining Guide
The Dining Culture
Nantucket's dining scene operates on a fundamentally different calendar from the mainland. From November through April, the island retreats — many restaurants close entirely, staff migrate south, and the year-round population of around 11,000 makes do with a handful of loyal establishments. Come May, the island wakes. By July, it is running at full tilt, and the best tables are gone weeks in advance.
The cuisine is rooted in New England's maritime tradition — oysters, scallops, lobster, striped bass, and bluefish from waters so close you can see them from your table — but Nantucket's wealthy seasonal population has historically demanded and received cooking that transcends the chowder-and-clam-roll register. The result is an island with a disproportionately sophisticated dining scene for its modest year-round size.
Bay scallop season, which opens in November, draws a specific kind of devotee. Nantucket bay scallops are considered among the finest shellfish in the world — sweet, tender, and entirely unlike what the inland supermarket calls a scallop. A trip to the island in late autumn, timed to this harvest, constitutes one of New England's most distinctive gastronomic pilgrimages.
Neighbourhoods & Where to Eat
The island's dining is concentrated in Nantucket Town, which is to say the cobblestoned streets of the historic district: India Street, Broad Street, Federal Street, and the wharf areas. Most of the restaurants listed on this page sit within a ten-minute walk of each other, which makes the town itself an entirely walkable dining destination.
The wharves — Straight Wharf, Old South Wharf, Straight Wharf, and the marina area — provide the island's best waterfront dining. CRU at Straight Wharf and Bar Yoshi at Old South Wharf represent the two poles of wharf-side dining: one grand and polished, the other counter-focused and intimate.
For those willing to venture out of town, Topper's at The Wauwinet sits at the island's eastern tip, accessible by complimentary jitney from the hotel or by the hotel's shuttle boat — a journey that frames the meal as the event it is. Galley Beach occupies its own headland on Nantucket Sound, south of town, requiring a short taxi ride that is entirely worth the fare.
Reservations & Practicalities
Book early. For July and August, four to six weeks in advance is the minimum for Topper's, Company of the Cauldron, and Galley Beach. CRU and Straight Wharf require two to three weeks. For walk-in dining during peak season, the bar at CRU, The Nautilus, and Brant Point Grill all maintain bar seating on a first-come basis — arrive by 5:30pm for the best chance.
Most restaurants operate seasonally from late April or May through October, with some extending into November for bay scallop season. Call or check websites before visiting in shoulder season. Dress codes are smart casual to dressy at most fine dining establishments — Topper's warrants proper dinner attire. Tipping follows standard US convention at 18-20 percent, though several restaurants add an automatic service charge; check your bill.