"Run by the Pizzi family since 1979, Ambrosia is Broad Ripple's enduring Italian — book it for an unhurried, old-school date."
Ambrosia has anchored 5903 N College Avenue in Broad Ripple since 1979, and the Pizzi family — founder Gino and now his daughters Manuela, Anna and Francesca — still runs the kitchen and the room. It is a classy-but-casual Italian restaurant that has outlasted every Indianapolis dining trend by refusing to chase them: linguine, veal Marsala and a wine list deep in Barolo need no reinvention.
The cooking is generous and rooted in Italian-American classics. Start with the baked goat-cheese torta or grilled shrimp wrapped in prosciutto, both long-standing favourites, then move to the meaty house lasagna or tortellini in a thick cream sauce with pancetta. Antipasti run to calamari, steamed mussels and grilled octopus, and the wine list — heavy on Barolo and Italian reds — is the reason regulars linger. Mains sit in the mid-to-upper range for the neighbourhood.
The dining room is warm and unfussy — white-cloth tables, low light and a long-serving staff that knows the regulars by name. It reads as a neighbourhood institution rather than a special-occasion-only address, though it handles both. Dinner only, with later hours on Friday and Saturday.
For a relaxed date, an anniversary or a low-key family celebration in Indianapolis, Ambrosia is the dependable Broad Ripple choice: classic Italian cooking, a deep Italian wine list and a room built for lingering rather than rushing.
Not for diners chasing the newest tasting-menu concept or a quick, cheap bite — Ambrosia is an old-school, sit-and-stay Italian where the appeal is consistency, not novelty.
Ambrosia opened in 1979 and has been run by the Pizzi family ever since, making it one of the longest-running Italian restaurants in Indianapolis's Broad Ripple neighbourhood.
Ambrosia is at 5903 N College Avenue in Broad Ripple, Indianapolis, IN 46220. It serves dinner only, with later hours on Friday and Saturday nights.
Long-standing favourites include the baked goat-cheese torta, grilled shrimp wrapped in prosciutto, the meaty house lasagna and tortellini in a cream sauce with pancetta.
Yes. Ambrosia is known for a wine list strong on Barolo and Italian reds, which is a large part of why regulars linger over dinner.
Yes. Its warm, white-cloth dining room and unhurried service make it a reliable choice for a relaxed date, an anniversary or a low-key family celebration.
Booking via OpenTable; we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Affiliate disclosure: Restaurants for Kings may earn a commission when you book through our reservation links, at no cost to you. Our scores are editorial and never paid for.
See where Ambrosia ranks among Indianapolis's tables, sorted by the occasion you're booking.
Read the Indianapolis guide →