The oldest red sauce in Hartford — ninety years of the same family, the same brick oven, and the same unshakable argument that this is where you take a date, a team, and a grandmother all in the same year.
The Generational Italian
Open in 1936. Same family. Same recipes. Same brick oven. The First and Last Tavern on Maple Avenue has been one of Hartford's defining restaurants for nearly nine decades — a tavern whose name comes from its location at the literal edge of the city limits, where it was both the first tavern inside the line and the last tavern on the way out. For most of the twentieth century it was a tradesmen's bar, a lunch counter where construction crews and shift workers ordered the "Original Special" — a plate of pasta, a meatball or sausage, and a small salad, served at the bar with a draft beer. That dish is still on the menu. It still costs something close to what your grandfather paid for it.
What the restaurant does today is broader than that one dish but still entirely faithful to it. The coal-fired brick-oven pizza is the main event: thin crust, blackened at the edges from the coal fire, topped with a red sauce that is genuinely different from any other red sauce in Hartford and that a local population will defend as the single best in the state. The sauce itself is the restaurant's talisman — the recipe has not changed, and it is the kind of sauce that inspires loyalty that outlasts marriages. Beyond the pizza: handmade pastas, baked ziti that fills the whole plate, chicken parm and veal parm that arrive at exactly the weight and attitude they have for sixty years, and a wine list that does not overreach.
The dining room is what a ninety-year Italian tavern has evolved into at its most honest — dark wood, framed photos, a long bar at the front, booths and tables at the back, and a staff that has often worked here long enough to know what your father's order was. It is one of the very few restaurants in downtown Hartford that does not require translation across generations.
Why It's Right for a Team Dinner
Because the First and Last Tavern understands a table of fifteen. The pizzas are made to be shared. The family-style pasta platters feed six without argument. The red sauce is nostalgic enough to be an icebreaker and specific enough to be a conversation. The check per head lands at exactly the price point a team dinner wants — meaningful enough to feel like an event, affordable enough to book again next quarter. For company dinners, extended family gatherings, and the post-little-league pizza parties that turned into wedding rehearsal dinners, this is the room Hartford sent its people to for ninety years. It still is.
Practical Intelligence
Community Verdict
Readers overwhelmingly file First and Last Tavern under Team Dinner and Birthday — the room is built for groups, and the value is hard to argue with anywhere in the city. A consistent First Date minority comes from Hartford natives who know the sauce is a conversation starter.
Best occasion for First and Last Tavern? — Team Dinner (36%) • Birthday (29%) • First Date (21%) • Solo Dining (14%). Register free to vote →
Reader Reviews
"Four generations of my family have ordered the same sausage pizza at the same back booth. My grandfather brought my father. My father brought me. I'm bringing my son. The sauce has not changed and I hope it never does." — Vincent M., Newington · Birthday
"Took our entire engineering team here for the year-end dinner — twenty-two of us, the back room, eight pizzas, four pasta platters, two bottles of Chianti per table. Everyone went home happy and the bill was a third of what the steakhouse would have been." — Karen R., Hartford · Team Dinner
Also Great in Hartford
Explore More
→ All restaurants in Hartford
→ Best restaurants for team dinners
→ Best restaurants for birthdays
→ Best restaurants for first dates
→ Explore New Haven · Providence · Boston