Old Town's Build-Your-Own Original
Stuft has occupied 210 South College for years, and in that time has built a regional reputation on a single, simple premise: build the burger you actually want. The menu hands you a meat — beef, bison, chicken, lamb, or a black-bean veggie patty — and then turns you loose on twenty-plus toppings. Caramelized onions. Fried egg. Roasted poblanos. House-made chile rellenos. Sweet-and-spicy bacon. Cheese curds. Fried pineapple. A glazed donut, if you want, in place of the bun.
The fries are the other headline. Stuft's Parmesan Garlic Fries were voted best in the state by Yahoo! Travel — a recognition that may sound small but means the kitchen has nailed the basics of cut, fry temperature, and finishing oil in a category most American restaurants get wrong. The seasoned fries, sweet potato fries, and tater tots all earn their place on the menu, but order the parmesan garlic at least once.
The room is loud and social — exposed brick, a long bar, communal-friendly tables, a couple of booths along the wall. Beer rotation favors Colorado craft, with rotating seasonal taps and a respectable bourbon shelf for the milkshake-and-bourbon order regulars place by name. Service is fast even when the room is full, which on a CSU football Saturday or a downtown event night is a small miracle.
This is not a special-occasion restaurant. It is the booking when six friends need to eat, when a team wants somewhere energetic that doesn't require a reservation, when a solo lunch wants something better than the chains. The build-your-own format is what makes the room: every plate is a different conversation, and the table never gets bored.
At a Glance
Why It Works for a Team Dinner
Stuft is built for groups. The build-your-own format means every personality at the table gets exactly what they want without a kitchen revolt — the picky eater, the vegetarian, the meat-and-potatoes regular, the one person who wants a burger on a glazed donut. The price point keeps the bill reasonable for a casual work or social team, and the energy of the room means a noisy table doesn't stand out. Service moves quickly enough that you can sit a team of ten and still be out within ninety minutes if the night calls for it.
For solo lunch, the bar gives you a comfortable single seat and a fast turnaround. For a low-stakes first date, the format generates conversation almost automatically — half the meal is just discussing what you both ordered.
Frequently Asked About Stuft
What is Stuft Burger Bar known for?
Build-your-own burgers — beef, bison, chicken, lamb, or veggie patty with twenty-plus toppings including chile rellenos, fried egg, sweet-and-spicy bacon, and a glazed donut bun option.
Are Stuft's fries worth ordering?
Yes. The Parmesan Garlic Fries were voted best in Colorado by Yahoo! Travel and remain the order to make at least once.
Does Stuft take reservations?
No — walk-in only. Tables turn quickly, even on busy nights.
Is Stuft Burger Bar good for groups?
Yes — the build-your-own format and casual energy make it ideal for groups of 4 to 12. Communal-friendly tables and a long bar mean even a larger party can be seated quickly.
Community Poll & Reviews
Vote on the best occasion for Stuft Burger Bar, rate your experience, and read what the community says. Join free to participate.
Join Free to Vote & Review