Restaurants for Kings · The King's List

The King's List
Key West

The finest tables in Key West, adjudicated by King's Score.
Living ranking · updates weekly
# The King's List — Key West The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. commands Old Town's dining scene with New American Seafood in the $$$ price band. Latitudes presents an elevated alternative on Sunset Key, offering Seafood at the $$$$ tier for those seeking maximum luxury.
1
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
New American Seafood · Old Town, Eaton Street · $$$
In contention
2
Latitudes
Seafood · Sunset Key (by ferry) · $$$$
In contention
3
Little Pearl
New American · Old Town · $$$
In contention
4
El Siboney Restaurant
Cuban · Old Town, Catherine Street · $$
In contention
5
Antonia's Restaurant
$$$
In contention
6
Louie's Backyard
Caribbean Fusion, New American · $$$
In contention
7
Hot Tin Roof
Conch-Fusion Seafood · Old Town, foot of Duval Street · $$$
In contention
8
Tavern N Town
New American · $$$
In contention
9
Cafe Marquesa
$$$
In contention
10
Café Solé
French, Seafood · Old Town, off Duval Street · $$$
In contention
11
Latitudes
Seafood &amp, beachfront, steak · On the private island of Sunset Key, a short launch from Mallory Square · $$$$
In contention
12
Azur Restaurant
$$$
In contention
13
Half Shell Raw Bar
Raw Bar, Seafood · Key West Historic Seaport · $$
In contention
14
Hogfish Bar & Grill
Florida Keys Seafood · Stock Island, Safe Harbour Marina · $$
In contention
15
Martin's
$$$
In contention
16
Nine One Five
$$$
In contention
17
Blue Heaven
Caribbean-American · Bahama Village, in a Dade County pine landmark · $$
In contention
18
First Flight
$$$
In contention
19
Lola's Bistro
$$$
In contention
20
Santiago's Bodega
Tapas · $$
In contention
How the order is decided

Tables with three or more member reviews rank on their King's Score — a trust-weighted 0–100 built from real diners and never from us — and always sit above the unreviewed field. Everything still In contention is held in a provisional, stable order until the Court weighs in. Arrows show movement since last week. Featured tables are labelled and never outrank an earned score.

All tables in Key West Ask the Concierge More lists