To understand what The Sawtooth Club means to Ketchum, consider that it has been voted the Valley's Best Overall Restaurant five consecutive years — not by food critics, but by the people who eat here repeatedly, year after year, and keep returning. Since 1937, when this building opened its doors to the first generation of Sun Valley ski visitors, the Sawtooth has occupied the intersection of community institution and serious restaurant that most establishments only aspire to.
The menu is built around the mesquite wood fire that has burned in this kitchen for generations. Every major protein — the mesquite-grilled ribeye, the filet mignon, the rack of lamb, the roasted free-range chicken — passes through its heat, and each emerges with the particular character that only live wood fire can impart: a crust that crackles, an interior that stays precisely where it should. The Idaho trout is fresh and handled with respect. The butternut squash ravioli is a perennial favourite among guests who arrive expecting red meat and discover they want something else entirely. Tom's Mom's Famous Meatloaf — listed by name on the menu — is a signature that has earned its place through decades of repeat orders.
The Sawtooth Club also does something that few restaurants in Sun Valley manage: it maintains two distinct atmospheres simultaneously. The bar is lively, social, and genuinely fun — a place where locals and visitors converge for Happy Hour (4:30 to 6pm) over well-made cocktails and animated conversation. The dining room is something else: romantic, quietly elegant, designed for lingering. The beautiful outdoor terrace, open from late May through September, adds a third dimension that takes advantage of Ketchum's improbable summer warmth.
The wine list is award-winning and reasonably priced by Sun Valley standards — a rarity in a valley where cellars are often padded with trophy bottles at trophy prices. The Sawtooth's list is curated for drinking rather than display, which is the correct philosophy. Happy Hour cocktails are consistently praised by regulars, and the bar service is fast and skilled.
For visitors who want one dinner that encapsulates what Sun Valley's dining culture is at its finest — historic, confident, seasonally intelligent, and entirely free of trends — The Sawtooth Club is the answer. Book ahead; the OpenTable availability reflects the room's ongoing popularity, but peak season fills weeks in advance.
Choosing The Sawtooth Club for a client dinner in Sun Valley communicates something specific: that you know this valley, that you respect its history, and that you understand the difference between a restaurant and an institution. Visiting executives who have never been to Ketchum will be impressed by the room's character and the food's confidence. The dual atmosphere — bar for loosening conversations, dining room for closing them — makes it structurally ideal for a deal dinner. The wine list's approachability removes the anxiety of selection without diminishing the occasion. And the five-year reign as the valley's best overall restaurant means you are bringing a guest somewhere that the town itself endorses. That endorsement travels.
Join Restaurants for Kings to read and submit verified guest reviews, rate your experience by occasion, and access our full community dining guide for Sun Valley and Ketchum.
Join Free →