Italian warmth in the oldest surviving house in Reykjavik. Where the 1801 Governor's residence now serves wood-fired pizza, risotto that earns its reputation, and a candlelit atmosphere that has saved more first dates than we will ever know.
8.5
Food
9
Ambience
8.5
Value
About Caruso
The building at Austurstraeti 22 was constructed in 1801 and served originally as the Governor's House — the residence of the Danish Crown's representative in Iceland, including at various points the legendary Jörgen Jörgensen, the self-proclaimed "Dog-Days King" who briefly declared Iceland an independent republic in 1809. The house has witnessed more of Iceland's history than any other surviving structure in central Reykjavik. Caruso has been inside it for over fifteen years, and the relationship has produced one of the city's most beloved dining institutions.
The restaurant is family-run, and this is not a description but a characterisation. The warmth of Caruso — the reason people return on anniversaries and bring guests who need to be impressed — originates in the care of the family that operates it. Italian cooking is, fundamentally, a family tradition. The best Italian restaurants anywhere in the world replicate the experience of eating in someone's home, with the skill of a professional kitchen. Caruso achieves this with apparent effortlessness.
The menu covers the expected Italian range: appetisers featuring local produce cooked occasionally in Italian style, wood-fired pizzas, handmade pasta, fish and meat mains. What distinguishes each from merely competent is the sourcing — the kitchen integrates Iceland's exceptional seafood and lamb into Italian preparations without apology, and the results reveal how compatible these culinary traditions are when both bring quality to the encounter. The risotto, frequently cited in reviews, demonstrates this fusion at its most confident: creamy, properly rested, built around Arctic seafood that gives the dish a flavour profile unavailable anywhere in Italy.
The garlic bread is not a detail to pass over. The pizza dough, fermented and wood-fired in the traditional manner, produces results that Reykjavik residents treat as a civic treasure. Children's and vegetarian menus ensure the restaurant serves groups of mixed appetite without compromise.
The Occasion Fit
Perfect for First Dates
Caruso possesses the two things a first date most requires: candlelight and a story. The building's 1801 origin and historical significance give both parties something extraordinary to discuss before the menus arrive. The Italian food is warm, shareable, and universally appealing — it lowers defences and creates pleasure simultaneously. The candlelit rooms are intimate enough for private conversation but not so hushed that silence becomes awkward. The family atmosphere wraps guests in a comfort that expensive, formal restaurants cannot replicate. This is first-date dining with the odds firmly in your favour.
The Experience
The dining rooms occupy multiple spaces within the historic house, each with the character imparted by centuries-old architecture — uneven floors, original walls, low ceilings in some rooms, the sensation throughout that the building has opinions about the people inside it. In summer, terrace seating in the historic courtyard is available, and dining under the midnight sun in Reykjavik's oldest courtyard is an experience that belongs in a specific category of singular evenings.
The wine list is Italian-focused and well-curated, with enough regional diversity to satisfy both experts and those who simply want something good with their pasta. Service is attentive and unpretentious — the staff know the menu thoroughly and make recommendations with the confidence of people who actually eat the food.
Caruso is located in the heart of central Reykjavik, steps from the main pedestrian street and the city's most concentrated hotel district. It is the restaurant that out-of-town guests are brought to when local residents want to show them something genuinely special without the pressure of Michelin formality. The phone number is +354 562 7335. Reservations are recommended, particularly on weekends and in summer.
