About Blue Moon
In an elegant Victorian beach house two blocks from the ocean on Baltimore Avenue, Blue Moon has held a position in Delaware's top ten restaurants for long enough that the ranking has become simply the baseline expectation rather than an achievement. Open since the 1980s, the restaurant has outlasted trends, economic cycles, and the particular pressures of a seasonal beach town economy through consistency of quality and the kind of atmosphere that a Victorian dining room — properly appointed, correctly lit, staffed by people who understand what hospitality means — can provide in a way that more modern establishments cannot.
The dinner menu reflects American cooking at its most accomplished within the beach-town context. Short rib stroganoff and roasted oysters are signatures that have remained on the menu because they work rather than because they define a brand. Seafood pasta, crab-stuffed shrimp, and the signature Moon Pie dessert complete a repertoire built over decades. Sunday brunch extends the restaurant's weekly presence for guests who stay the full weekend. The Atrium Lounge provides year-round entertainment — live music on the schedule available through the restaurant's website — in a space that accommodates the particular pleasures of drinking and listening in a comfortable room.
Blue Moon is open for dinner Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday through Saturday, and for Sunday brunch and dinner. Wednesday closures are the rhythm of a restaurant that paces itself through the season. The Thursday-through-Saturday dinner service covers the core weekend demand; Sunday brunch and dinner serves the guests who have extended their Delaware shore weekend into the early week.
Baltimore Avenue itself is one of Rehoboth Beach's most pleasant streets: tree-lined, walkable, close to the Boardwalk without the foot traffic of Rehoboth Avenue. The Victorian house is visible from the street and functions as its own landmark.
Why It Is Perfect for First Date
Blue Moon works for a first date because it has been working for first dates for decades — the Victorian setting, the candlelight, the lounge entertainment, and the menu's range from oysters to short rib stroganoff create the conditions that a first date requires without demanding that either person perform enthusiasm about the choice. Delaware residents and visitors from Washington and Baltimore who know where to eat already know about Blue Moon. For someone who wants to demonstrate knowledge of the Delaware shore dining scene, it is the correct answer. For someone encountering it for the first time, it is immediately legible as a serious and beautiful restaurant.
Practical Information
Community Poll
What is Blue Moon best for?
Guest Reviews
What diners are saying about Blue Moon
Back to all restaurants in Rehoboth Beach — See the First Date dining guide — Explore all cities — Read our Delaware Beach dining blog