Best Anniversary Restaurants in Encinitas (2026)
Published · Updated
The Encinitas anniversary table for 2026 is Herb & Sea, chef Brian Malarkey's seafood room in a restored 1920s art deco building a walk from Moonlight Beach. Editorial runners-up: VAGA at Alila Marea, Pacific Coast Grill, Valentina, Buona Forchetta.
Brian Malarkey built Herb & Wood in San Diego's Little Italy before bringing the coastal version north to a 1920s building on West D Street, and Trattoria I Trulli has held South Coast Highway since June 2000; Encinitas keeps its anniversary tables on the 101 and over the water. Sixteen of the town's rooms sit in our directory, and six earn the date.
Six Encinitas Tables for an Anniversary
Brian Malarkey, known for Herb & Wood in San Diego's Little Italy, brought his coastal cooking north to a restored 1920s art deco building at 131 West D Street, a short walk from Moonlight Beach, with chef Aidan Owens running the day-to-day kitchen. The room handles a seasonal raw bar and sustainable fish with the polish Malarkey's group demands of its rooms. The town's most serious seafood address; book it for an anniversary that wants a proper occasion near the sand.
Executive chef Tim Crittenden brought two decades from hotel kitchens, Austin Proper and the Park Hyatt Washington among them, to VAGA at the Alila Marea Beach Resort, 2100 North Coast Highway, where the dining room looks straight out over the Pacific. The duck carnitas is a recurring signature, rendered to a lacquered finish against pickled accompaniments. The resort room on this list; reserve an ocean-view table at sunset for an anniversary that wants the whole view.
Pacific Coast Grill sits oceanfront in Cardiff-by-the-Sea across two levels, the most direct beach-and-water setting on this list, where the Pacific runs right up to the windows. The kitchen leans on seafood, the upstairs deck catches the sunset, and the room handles a special occasion without ceremony. Book the upper deck before dusk for an anniversary built around the view and the tide.
Valentina works a modern European and Spanish menu in downtown Encinitas on North Coast Highway 101, where most guests eat extremely well for $55 to $90 a head. In a beach town where pricier tapas rooms have become the norm, that makes it one of the smarter value plays on the 101, with cooking that holds up against rooms charging more. A relaxed, well-priced anniversary; book a weekend table a few days ahead.
Buona Forchetta's Encinitas room at 250 North Coast Highway 101 is the group's third location, pairing award-winning Neapolitan pizza from the oven with a Northern Italian evening menu, osso buco, braised short rib, handmade tagliolini and ravioli. Pies run $18 to $26 and pastas $22 to $32, keeping a full anniversary dinner well under control. The warm-family option; book it for a celebration that wants Italian comfort over formality.
Trattoria I Trulli has held South Coast Highway 101 since June 2000, the kind of Italian room that other restaurants spend decades trying to become, genuinely loved and consistent without chasing trends. At an average $20 to $30 a head it is among the best value on the Encinitas stretch of the 101, anchored by cooking that does not need novelty to stay relevant. The neighbourhood-institution pick; book it for an anniversary that returns to a known table.
For a Michelin-recognised daytime alternative, Atelier Manna on North Coast Highway 101 holds a 2025 Bib Gourmand for its morning cooking, an option for an anniversary marked over a long brunch rather than dinner.
How to Book
Herb & Sea and VAGA want several days to a week for a weekend evening, especially a sunset table; Pacific Coast Grill's upper deck fills fast on clear nights. Valentina, Buona Forchetta and Trattoria I Trulli usually take a few days' notice.
Aim for the half-hour before sunset on the coast, VAGA at Alila Marea and the Pacific Coast Grill deck both peak as the light drops over the water. Tell them it is an anniversary and Herb & Sea and VAGA will seat you accordingly.
Frequently Asked Questions
The editorial pick for 2026 is Herb & Sea, chef Brian Malarkey's seafood room in a restored 1920s art deco building on West D Street, a walk from Moonlight Beach. For an oceanfront resort evening, VAGA at the Alila Marea Beach Resort puts the Pacific directly in view from chef Tim Crittenden's dining room.
VAGA at the Alila Marea Beach Resort and Pacific Coast Grill in Cardiff-by-the-Sea are the two most romantic rooms, each with the Pacific in view and a deck angled at the sunset. Herb & Sea is the more design-driven choice, a restored art deco interior steps from Moonlight Beach rather than directly over the water.
Plan on $90 to $150 a head at VAGA, the resort room at the top of the range, and roughly $70 to $110 at Herb & Sea or Pacific Coast Grill before wine. Valentina runs $55 to $90, and Buona Forchetta and Trattoria I Trulli are the gentle bills at the $$ tier, often under $40 a person.
Book Herb & Sea and VAGA several days to a week ahead for a weekend evening, and earlier still for a sunset table, since both fill fast on the coast. Pacific Coast Grill's upper deck goes quickly on clear nights, while Valentina, Buona Forchetta and Trattoria I Trulli usually take a few days' notice.
VAGA at the Alila Marea Beach Resort on North Coast Highway and Pacific Coast Grill in Cardiff-by-the-Sea both look directly over the Pacific, with decks built for the sunset. Reserve a table for the half-hour before dusk, when the light drops over the water and the coast settles into the evening.