Columbus’s Greatest Tables
5 restaurants listedGet the complete Columbus dining guide.
New openings, reservation tips, and editor picks — updated quarterly. Free to join.
$ under $40 · $$ $40–$80 · $$$ $80–$150 · $$$$ $150+ per person
Best for First Date in Columbus
Best for Business Dinner in Columbus
The Top 5 Columbus Restaurants
Agni
Agni opened in 2023 on the southern edge of the Brewery District at 716 South High Street - effectively on the German Village border - and within two years had collected a Bon Appetit Top 20 New Restaurants of 2024 nod, a USA Today Restaurants of the Year 2025 placement, and a 2025 James Beard Award nomination for chef-owner Avishar Barua in the Best Chef: Great Lakes category. Barua trained in New York at Wylie Dufresne's WD~50 and Atera, returned to Columbus to open Joya's in Worthington in 2021, and built Agni as his second project around a single conceptual spine: a fourteen-course tasting menu centered on a wood-fired grill that maps the chef's biography (Bengali-Bangladeshi family, midwest American upbringing, modernist New York fine-dining training) onto each plate.
The Refectory
The Refectory opened in 1981 inside a restored 1853 Methodist church on Bethel Road in northwest Columbus, ten minutes by car from downtown and from the Ohio State University campus. The building itself is the room's defining feature: thirty-foot ceilings, original nineteenth-century stained glass at the chancel end, exposed timber beams across the nave, and a main dining room that occupies what was once the sanctuary. The restaurant has held AAA Four Diamond standing for more than thirty consecutive years - making it the only restaurant in Columbus and one of fewer than three hundred restaurants in the United States to maintain that recognition across that timeframe - and is the only Ohio restaurant to have ever received Wine Spectator's Grand Award.
Veritas
Veritas opened in Delaware, Ohio in 2012 under chef-owner Josh Dalton, was named Best New Restaurant in Columbus within six months of opening, and moved to its current downtown address at 11 West Gay Street in early 2018. The dining room runs as the only tasting-menu-only restaurant in downtown Columbus: a sixty-seat space across two connected rooms with a sleek modernist interior of dark walnut, brass detailing, soft pendant lighting and a partially open kitchen at the back wall that lets diners watch the line work the seven-to-ten-course evening menu.
Lindey's
Lindey's has occupied the 1884 brick corner building at the southwest corner of Beck and Mohawk streets in the heart of German Village since 1981. The building's history runs deeper still - across nearly a century-and-a-half it has housed a grocery, at least two saloons, a hardware store, and (per local historical-marker text) an alleged Prohibition-era speakeasy - and the current restaurant has been continuously voted one of Columbus's top dining rooms by Columbus Monthly's Best Restaurants survey for more than thirty-eight consecutive years. The dining room is structured across three main rooms - the front bar, the formal main dining room with original artwork and copper-topped bars, and a back conservatory - plus three private party rooms upstairs and the award-winning brick-walled outdoor courtyard that OpenTable has named one of the Top 100 Patios in America.
Hiraeth
Hiraeth opened in 2023 in a new-build two-story corner at 36 East Lincoln Street and Pearl Alley in the Short North, the city's most active dining-and-gallery district immediately north of downtown. The restaurant is the second project from the team behind Chapman's (the chef-driven Italian Village kitchen that has been a Columbus Monthly Top 10 fixture across multiple years) and the name - hiraeth - is a Welsh word that translates roughly as a longing for a home, a place, a person, or a time that may never return. The dining room runs across two floors with an open kitchen centred on a wood-burning oven that is visible from every seat in the downstairs main room and from the railing along the upstairs mezzanine. The aesthetic is warm and intentional: aged oak banquettes, hand-glazed ceramic tile across the open-kitchen pass, a single long marble bar at the entrance, and large arched windows along Lincoln Street that flood the room with natural light at golden hour.
