The Restaurant
40 Paper occupies the ground floor of a restored 19th-century commercial building at 40 Washington Street — one block north of Main Street, in the quieter dining quadrant of downtown Camden. The room reads deliberately as a European bistro: exposed brick, original Maine pine floors, low pendant lighting over a long bar, an open kitchen window line, and a series of two-tops along the front window that gives the room its evening character. The dining floor seats about seventy, with a small private back room for groups of ten to fourteen. The format is unhurried — the kitchen opens at 4:00pm sharp, holds a 4-to-6pm aperitivo hour, and runs dinner service through 8:00pm.
The kitchen serves a focused modern-Italian menu with deliberate Mediterranean inflections — ingredients and techniques from Spain, southern France, and coastal North Africa show up across the carte. Signature plates include a hand-cut tagliatelle with slow-braised Maine lamb sugo and gremolata, a pan-seared local halibut with saffron-mussel broth and roasted fennel, a Tuscan-style ribollita with garden vegetables and crisp pancetta, a wood-oven Neapolitan-style pizza programme with seasonal toppings, and the room's signature lobster ravioli in a butter-saffron emulsion that has been on the menu since 40 Paper opened. The cured-meat and Italian-cheese boards — fifteen producers across both — are the working aperitivo order.
The wine programme runs Italian-first and Mediterranean-deep — about a hundred and fifty labels with serious depth in Etna Rosso, Aglianico, Friulian whites, and a small but considered selection of southern Rhône and Catalan reds. The by-the-glass programme rotates monthly and includes both classical pairings and a deliberately adventurous orange-wine and natural-skin-contact rotation. The cocktail list is short and accurate — a classical Negroni programme, a deliberate house Aperol Spritz that uses Italian prosecco rather than the supermarket version, and a small amaro and grappa list that the bar staff narrates without overselling. For a Camden evening that wants the format right rather than the headline volume, 40 Paper is the village's quietly serious answer.
Why This Is Camden’s First Date Pick
For a Camden first date that needs to register as a real evening rather than a coffee-and-walk, 40 Paper delivers the format with rare precision. The brick-walled room is intimate at every table — there is no bad seat, no overhead-lit booth that flattens a face, no acoustic hot zone that forces a raised voice. The aperitivo hour at 4:00pm gives a date the option to start light — a glass of Etna Bianco, a salumi board, an unhurried first hour at the bar — before settling into a full dinner if the conversation holds. The Italian-first wine list is broad enough to signal taste without requiring a sommelier round, and the by-the-glass programme means a date can drift across three or four producers across an evening. The Washington Street setting — quieter than Main, lit by the original village street lamps — is the photograph the date takes home.
Leave a Review
Registered members get published by default; guest reviews are moderated first.